LLC partners not getting along: your options under Michigan law

Short answer: Start with your operating agreement. It usually controls voting, buyouts and how a member can leave. If the people in control are freezing you out, hiding the books or using the company for themselves, Michigan law lets a member sue for "member oppression" (MCL 450.4515), and a court can order a buyout, damages or, in some cases, dissolution. Strict time limits apply, so don't wait years to act.

Most LLCs start with two or three people who trust each other. Then the money gets tight, one partner stops pulling their weight, or one side takes over the bank account. If you are in a Michigan LLC and the relationship has broken down, here are your realistic options.

Step one: read the operating agreement

The operating agreement is the rulebook. Look for:

  • Voting and management: Is the LLC run by all members or by named managers? What needs a majority, and what needs everyone?
  • Buy-sell or buyout terms: Many agreements set out how a member can be bought out and how the price is figured.
  • Withdrawal: Under Michigan law, a member can generally withdraw only if the operating agreement allows it (MCL 450.4509).
  • Deadlock and dispute clauses: Mediation, arbitration or a "shotgun" buy-sell provision.
  • Expulsion: Some agreements let the other members remove a member for specific reasons.

No written agreement? Then the default rules in the Michigan Limited Liability Company Act fill the gaps, which often makes it harder for anyone to force an exit.

Your right to see the books

A member doesn't have to guess what's happening with the money. Under MCL 450.4503, a member can make a written request for the company's recent financial statements and tax returns and can inspect and copy the records the LLC is required to keep. A formal written records request is often the first move, because the response, or the refusal, tells you a lot.

When it becomes "member oppression"

MCL 450.4515 lets a member sue when the managers or members in control act illegally, fraudulently, or in a "willfully unfair and oppressive" way toward the company or toward that member. Examples courts look at include:

  • Cutting a member off from distributions while the controlling side still gets paid
  • Firing a member from their job at the company in a way that wipes out their share of the profits
  • Diverting customers, money or opportunities to another business the controlling member owns
  • Refusing to share financial information

One important limit: conduct that the operating agreement actually allows generally can't be "oppressive," even if it feels unfair. That's why the agreement matters so much.

If oppression is proven, the court can order a range of remedies, including requiring the company or the other members to buy your interest at fair value, awarding damages, or dissolving the company.

Watch the clock. A member-oppression claim for damages generally must be filed within 3 years after the claim arises, or within 2 years after you discovered (or should have discovered) it, whichever comes first (MCL 450.4515(1)(e)). The Michigan Supreme Court has held that the clock can start when the controlling side first substantially interferes with your rights, not when you finally add up the losses. If you've been frozen out for a while, talk to a lawyer soon.

Other options

  • Negotiated buyout: Often the fastest and cheapest exit. Get a business valuation and put the terms in writing.
  • Mediation: A neutral third party can break a deadlock without a trial.
  • Judicial dissolution: A circuit court can dissolve an LLC that can no longer carry on business in line with its articles or operating agreement (MCL 450.4802). This is usually a last resort.
  • Other claims: Depending on the facts, breach of the operating agreement, breach of fiduciary duty, or an accounting.

What to do now

  1. Get a copy of the operating agreement and any amendments.
  2. Pull together bank statements, tax returns (K-1s) and emails or texts about money and decisions.
  3. Write down when you were cut off from money, information or decisions. Dates matter for the deadline.
  4. Send requests in writing, not just by phone.
  5. Don't take money out of the company or lock your partner out yourself. Self-help can turn you into the defendant.

Learn more about our business dispute cases, or read what to do if your business has been served with a lawsuit.

Partner dispute in your LLC?

Send us your operating agreement and tell us what's going on. We'll explain your options. نتكلم العربية.

📞 Call (313) 566-4802Send a message